How generous were the wise men really? (2024)

St Matthew tells us that the first people to give presents at Christmas time were 'wise men from the east' who came following a star in search of a new-born king of the Jews. On finally locating the baby Jesus in Bethlehem, they fell down and worshipped him, honouring him with gifts of gold, frankincense and myrrh.

Astronomers have since devoted a great deal of time and effort trying to work out exactly what celestial phenomenon the wise men were following, coming up with some truly wild and wonderful theories in the process.

Financial analysts, however, have spent rather less time trying to calculate the contemporary market value of the wise men's presents.

So let's give it a go.

Gold, frankincense and myrrh were certainly highly prized 2,000 years ago; they were undoubtedly the luxury goods of the age. Gold, of course, is still familiar to us today; frankincense and myrrh perhaps less so.

Frankincense is the fragrant resin of a scraggy shrub that grows high on the inaccessible and inhospitable mountains that range the border of the Omani province of Dhofar and the notoriously-lawless Yemeni province of Hadramaut.

In the ancient world, frankincense was valued for the sharp and heady scent of its smoke and widely used in sacred rites. Its religious use is rarer today but the resin is still harvested as an ingredient of the perfume Amouage, a scent so blisteringly expensive it is sold in solid gold bottles.

Myrrh, another resin, comes mainly from the Horn of Africa. In the ancient world it played a central role in funereal rites, not least because its heavy sweet smell when burned is powerful enough to mask the odour of corruption.

We know that all three - gold, frankincense and myrrh - were certainly pricey 2,000 years ago but working out just how expensive is tricky.

Let's start with gold. Unfortunately St Matthew does not tell us how much gold the wise men gave. But it is reasonable to assume, since they were intent on venerating a divine king, they would not have wanted to appear stingy.

If we assume that the standard weight for golden royal regalia is the 42 ounce Sovereign's Orb of the British crown jewels, we can imagine that the wise men's gift weighed at least as much. In metric terms that means 1.3 kilograms of gold, valued today at a shade over US$34,000; generous certainly, but not beyond the bounds of possibility for those anxious to curry favour with a god-king.

Of course, values were different then and unfortunately price data for First Century Palestine are sketchy.

Sketchy is not quite the same as non-existent, however. St Matthew also tells us that roughly 30 years later Judas Iscariot was able to buy a field near Jerusalem with the 30 pieces of silver he received for betraying Christ.

The coins in question were half shekels from the temple treasury and each contained roughly seven grams of silver. In the ancient world, fields came in standard sizes of 100 cubits by 100 cubits or roughly 2,500 square metres.

So 210 grams of silver was sufficient to purchase 2,500 square metres on the outskirts of the old city of Jerusalem. If we assume that the relative value of gold and silver has held steady at 57 to 1 ever since, then the wise men's golden gift would have been able to purchase an impressive 882,000 square metres of property near Jerusalem.

A quick trawl of the internet reveals agricultural land in Israel being offered for sale today at US$44.27 per square metre. That means that the wise men's gift of gold to Jesus would have a purchasing power in 2007 of an astonishing US$39 million; no small present.

The internet also tells us that frankincense can be bought today for US$100 a kilogram and good quality myrrh for something similar. But it is fair to assume that fragrant gums are a debased currency today. In the ancient world, the transport costs alone would have been ruinous. Certainly incense was costly enough for Leonidas to rebuke a young Alexander the Great for his extravagance when he burned an entire handful of myrrh.

In all probability we can assume from St Matthew's ordering of the words 'gold, and frankincense, and myrrh' that he felt the gift of gold to have been the least impressive of the three.

Working on that assumption, we can estimate that the current purchasing power of the wise men's gifts to the baby Jesus would be somewhere over US$120 million.

That sounds a lot, but when you consider that it is less than a fifth of what the Hong Kong government plans to spend on its new headquarters, then you must conclude either that the wise men were being somewhat miserly with their presents, or that Donald Tsang has got ideas far above his station. Happy Christmas.

How generous were the wise men really? (1)

How generous were the wise men really? (2024)

FAQs

How much were the wise men's gifts worth? ›

However, it is agreed three gifts were brought. The gifts, which the three men carried, were fit for a King. Equivalent to today's prices, a pound of frankincense was worth $500 a pound, and a pound of myrrh was $4,000. Today, each are priced at approximately $15 a pound.

What do we really know about the wise men? ›

No one knows for sure how many wise men went to Bethlehem to honor Jesus as the newborn king of the Jews. Tradition says there were three wise men and there may have been. We do know that the wise men came from the east of Bethlehem “following yonder star.” However they did not arrive on the night that Jesus was born.

What happened to the gold the wise men brought to Jesus? ›

What subsequently happened to these gifts is never mentioned in the scripture, but several traditions have developed. One story has the gold being stolen by the two thieves who were later crucified alongside Jesus. Another tale has it being entrusted to and then misappropriated by Judas.

What ethnicity were the wise men? ›

The magi were a Median Kurdish priestly caste or tribe who rose to prominence in ancient Persia (today's Iran). Their religion, Zoroastri-anism, originated around the Sixth Century BC after the Median Zoroaster (the name itself possibly means "dawn star").

Was myrrh worth more than gold? ›

The sacred trees that produce Frankincense and Myrrh are almost impossible to grow outside of the Arabian Peninsula, which meant they were constantly in short supply and high demand. According to a famous Roman historian, the sap made the Arabians the richest people on earth by Jesus's time, more valuable than gold.

How much does myrrh cost today? ›

Montana-based Aromatics International sells a pound of frankincense resin online for $41.99, about $2.63 an ounce, while myrrh resin sells for $36.99 a pound or $2.32 an ounce.

What did Mary and Joseph do with the gold, frankincense, and myrrh? ›

An alternative tradition holds that Mary and Joseph used the gold to pay for the stable, the frankincense to perfume it and the myrrh as an ointment for the new-born baby.

What religion were the Magi? ›

Islamic tradition

In Arabic, "Magians" (majus) is the term for Zoroastrians. The term is mentioned in the Quran, in sura 22 verse 17, where the "Magians" are mentioned alongside the Jews, the Sabians and the Christians in a list of religions who will be judged on the Day of Resurrection.

Were the wise men really kings? ›

The Magi had a lively postbiblical career. As early as the 2nd century, they were promoted to kings, probably because frankincense is associated with royalty in one of the Psalms. Their number, which varied in different accounts from two to 12, eventually settled on three, most likely because of their three gifts.

Why did Melchior give gold to Jesus? ›

Upon arriving at the house, the Magi worshipped him and opened their gifts, with Melchior giving the gift of gold to signify Jesus' kingship over the world.

How long after Jesus' birth did the Magi come? ›

According to the Gospel of Matthew, the men found the divine child in Bethlehem by following the North Star across the desert. According to later writings, the Kings (Melchior from Europe, Caspar from Arabia, and Balthazar from Africa) arrived twelve days after Jesus' birth.

How old was Mary when she had Jesus? ›

Her age during her pregnancy has varied up to 17 in apocryphal sources. In a large part, apocryphal texts are historically unreliable. According to ancient Jewish custom, Mary technically could have been betrothed at about 12, but some scholars hold the view that in Judea it typically happened later.

Were the wise men pagan? ›

These wise men were not Jews, nor did they have a faith. In fact, they were pagan magicians and astrologers from the east, sometimes called the Magi.

Who was the black wise man? ›

Since King Balthazar, in traditional pictorial representations from the Late Middle Ages, is often represented as a black person (as an integrating or cosmopolitan graphic symbol, in the tradition that the "wise men" or "magi" who worshipped Jesus in Bethlehem represented the peoples of the whole world), fitting in ...

Were the three wise men rich? ›

These luxurious gifts indicate that these visitors from the East “are people of great wealth and power, that's kind of obvious based on the things they bring,” says Swenson. “They are called Magi in the Greek, which was a term that referred to a kind of subclass of Persian priests.

What was the value of myrrh in biblical times? ›

Many estimate that at that time, translated into modern money, frankincense would have cost $500 per pound. Myrrh would have cost $4,000 per pound. While much is known about the gifts themselves, the bearers, known as the Magi or “Wise Men,” remain somewhat mysterious to modern scholars.

How much gold did the 3 wise men bring? ›

In metric terms that means 1.3 kilograms of gold, valued today at a shade over US$34,000; generous certainly, but not beyond the bounds of possibility for those anxious to curry favour with a god-king.

Were frankincense and myrrh expensive? ›

Because ancient societies of Egyptians, Greeks, and Romans burned frankincense or myrrh incense during rituals, these resins were in high demand and expensive due to the tolls, taxes, and labor expenses incurred when transporting them across treacherous routes to markets.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Margart Wisoky

Last Updated:

Views: 6133

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (78 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Margart Wisoky

Birthday: 1993-05-13

Address: 2113 Abernathy Knoll, New Tamerafurt, CT 66893-2169

Phone: +25815234346805

Job: Central Developer

Hobby: Machining, Pottery, Rafting, Cosplaying, Jogging, Taekwondo, Scouting

Introduction: My name is Margart Wisoky, I am a gorgeous, shiny, successful, beautiful, adventurous, excited, pleasant person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.