Jello Cookies - My Incredible Recipes (2024)

These Jello Cookies are made with a scrumptious sugar cookie dough that is then colored and flavored with different flavors of jello. Each color of the cookies is bursting with fruity flavor and melts in your mouth. Try these Jello sugar cookies today.

This is a quick cookie recipe you can throw together and kids and adults will go crazy for them. You can pick any flavor of jello mix you would like. Both Kid-Friendly and Adult-Approved: The charm of Jello cookies transcends age barriers, making them a perfect treat for children and adults alike. Kids will be enchanted by their vibrant appearance, while adults will appreciate the nostalgic familiarity of beloved childhood flavors in a cookie form. Sharing these delightful cookies with loved ones becomes an opportunity to create lasting memories for both children and grown-ups.

Why you will love these Jello Cookies

• A homemade sugar cookie dough base.
• Fruity-flavored cookies that are made with boxed jello mixes. Do as many or as few flavors of jello as you would like.
• These cookies can be made ahead of time if you would like, up to one day.
• Kid-friendly and adult approved.
• This is such an easy cookie recipe to make.

Ingredients Needed

• Butter – Unsalted and softened is recommended. If you use salted butter just leave the butter out of the recipe.
• Granulated Sugar – The perfect way to sweeten the cookie dough.
• Eggs – Reach for large eggs that are at room temperature.
• Flour – All-purpose flour that is scooped into the measuring cup and leveled off.
• Vanilla – This will sweeten and balance the flavors in the cookie.
• Baking Powder and Baking Soda – These two ingredients are imperative for the cookies. It creates a soft and chewy texture and acts as a leavening agent.
• Salt – Make sure to use salt as it will blend all the flavors together.
• Jello – Reach for any flavor of Jello you would like. We did four different colors.

How to Make

Full steps on how to make the cookies are below in the recipe card. If you’re a fan of colorful desserts that are as pleasing to the eyes as they are to the taste buds, then brace yourself for an extraordinary treat – Jello Cookies! These vibrant, easy-to-make cookies are a fun twist on a classic recipe, enchanting both children and adults alike. So, let’s dive into the mesmerizing world of Jello cookies and learn how to create these delightful, whimsical treats at home.

Baking Tips For Success

• Make sure to cream the butter and sugar for at least 2-3 minutes. This is going to help create a super light texture for the cookies.
• Rolling the cookies into one-inch balls is needed. You want the dough balls to be evenly shaped so all the cookies bake evenly.
• You do not have to roll cookies in sugar if you don’t want the crunchy coating.
• Make sure to scrape the sides of the bowl as you mix the dough, to ensure it fully mixes.

Storing

Room Temperature – Make sure to keep the cookies in an airtight container or sealed bag. Make sure to get eall the air out of the bag to prevent it from drying out. The cookies will store for about a week.

Freezing – You are more than welcome to freeze any cookies you do not eat right away. Just place in the freezer in a proper container for 5-6 months. Then thaw on the counter when you are ready to serve.

FAQs

Can you use any flavor of Jello?

Of course! From a glassic cherry to blue raspberry, to Jolly Rancher flavored cookies. Feel free to use any jello you want.

What do the jello cookies taste like?

They are a fruity cookie that remind me of Fruity Pebbles cereal. You will find depending on the flavor of jello the flavor varies a bit. But you have the cookie flavor that blends with the jello for a twist in flavor.

Can I double the cookies with jello recipe?

Yes, you are more than welcome to double the cookie recipe if you want. Just use a large enough bowl for mixing. Then bake in batches.

Can I make Jello cookies with a Jello mix that doesn’t contain sugar?

So you can use a sugar free jello but know it will affect the texture and flavor of the cookies a bit. Just whip them up and bake the same as with a regular jello.

One of the most exciting aspects of Jello cookies is the wide range of vibrant flavors available. From distinctive fruity options like strawberry, orange, and lime, to the more unique flavors like blue raspberry or tropical fusion, the choices are seemingly endless. This versatility allows you to experiment with different flavors and mix them up to suit your preferences, guaranteeing a burst of color and taste in each cookie bite.

Whether you’re an experienced baker or just a beginner, Jello cookies are a hassle-free and enjoyable baking adventure. By incorporating powdered Jello mix into a traditional sugar cookie recipe, you effortlessly infuse your cookies with vibrant hues. The process involves blending the Jello mix with the cookie dough, shaping the dough into small balls, and baking them to perfection. The result? Soft, flavorful, and visually stunning cookies that the whole family will love.

Can I add mix-ins to Jello cookies?

Feel free to add in sprinkles or even mini chocolate chips. You are more than welcome to stir in either for the cookies. You can place a few chocolate chips on top of the cookies so that as they bake the chips are on top.

Perfect for Creative Customization: Beyond their vivid colors, Jello cookies pose a fantastic opportunity for creative customization. Decorate them with colorful sprinkles, drizzle a light glaze on top, or add a touch of frosting to enhance their visual appeal. You can even sandwich two cookies together with a creamy filling for a fun twist. The options are endless, championing your inner artist and inspiring you to experiment with various designs and finishes.

More Recipes You Will Love!

Strawberry Jello Cake with Strawberry Buttercream Frosting

Strawberry Cake Mix Cookies with Strawberry Lemon Glaze

Lemon Cake Mix Cookies with a Zesty Lemon Glaze